| Position | First Name | Last Name | College | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| M | Jeff | Ziegler | Messiah | 2004 |
| M | Ryan | Williams | Washington | 2004 |
| M | Trey | Speers | Messiah | 2004 |
| M | Jeremy | Sieverts | Maryland | 2004 |
| A | Andrew | Rheinhart | Ohio State | 2004 |
| D | Andrew | Mace | Gettysburg | 2004 |
| M | Kyle | Loda | St. Andrews | 2004 |
| A | Brandon | Johnson | Robert Morris | 2004 |
| M | James | Fitzella | Mary Washington | 2004 |
| D | Cole | Cockrum | Lynchburg | 2004 |
| D | AJ | Benson | Gordon | 2004 |
| M | Rob | Battle | Navy | 2004 |
| M | Andrew | Stimmel | Ohio State | 2005 |
| M | Bryce | Simantel | Presbyterian | 2005 |
| A | Dom | Scalzo | Rutgers | 2005 |
| M | Charles | Saylor | Mercyhurst | 2005 |
| M | Brendan | Ryan | Salisbury | 2005 |
| A | Derek | Pino | Mercyhurst | 2005 |
| A | Matt | Mercer | Salisbury | 2005 |
| D | Chris | McDonald | RIT | 2005 |
| D | Andrew | Mace | Gettysburg | 2005 |
| M | Kevin | Kelly | Towson | 2005 |
| D | Scott | Foreman | Ohio State | 2005 |
| D | Brian | Farrell | Maryland | 2005 |
| D | Chris | Eline | Mercyhurst | 2005 |
| D | Barney | Ehrmann | Georgetown | 2005 |
| M | Michael | Bryan | UMBC | 2005 |
| D | Ryan | Boyce | Presbyterian | 2005 |
| A | Thomas | Wood | North Carolina | 2006 |
| M | Jim | Sturges | Undecided | 2006 |
| M | Ben | Simmons | Salisbury | 2006 |
| A | Dom | Scalzo | Rutgers | 2006 |
| D | Andrew | Purdie | Kentucky | 2006 |
| M | Mike | Parker | Washington | 2006 |
| M | Adam | Paranka | Air Force | 2006 |
| D | Drew | Palmer | Fairfield | 2006 |
| A | Austin | Northcutt | St. Andrews | 2006 |
| G | Zach | Nash | Mercyhurst | 2006 |
| M | Dana | Moore II | Mercyhurst | 2006 |
| M | JJ | Miller | Messiah | 2006 |
| D | Tim | Marshall | RIT | 2006 |
| M | Brian | Madden | RIT | 2006 |
| M | Grant | Leighty | Messiah | 2006 |
| M | Drew | Kuechler | Robert Morris | 2006 |
| M | Justin | King | Christopher Newport | 2006 |
| A | Chase | Horning | UC Santa Barbara | 2006 |
| D | Sean | Hatley | St. Mary's | 2006 |
| D | Patrick | Harner | Saint Joseph's | 2006 |
| A | Eric | Hanover | Ohio State | 2006 |
| D | Taylor | Gunter | UC San Diego | 2006 |
| M | Ryan | Gray | Mercyhurst | 2006 |
| A | Thomas | Ghidotti | Army | 2006 |
| D | Sam | Eckert | St. Mary's | 2006 |
| M | Jack | Dudley | Cornell | 2006 |
| A | Tyler | Dolphin | Ohio State | 2006 |
| D | Nathan | Dalphini | Gordon | 2006 |
| M | Kevin | Coholan | Mercyhurst | 2006 |
| G | Mike | Chubbs | Howard CC | 2006 |
| A | Grant | Catalino | Maryland | 2006 |
| M | William | Bell | Undecided | 2006 |
| A | Damian | Becker | Virginia Wesleyan | 2006 |
| D | Jake | Ziegler | Jacksonville | 2007 |
| M | Pete | Wujciak | Providence | 2007 |
| D | Kacey | Woods | Towson | 2007 |
| A | Thomas | Wood | North Carolina | 2007 |
| D | Peter | Windsor | St. Mary's | 2007 |
| D | Kyle | Virtue | Gettysburg | 2007 |
| D | Colin | Valkenet | Emerson | 2007 |
| M | Brian | Smalley | Loyola | 2007 |
| D | Sean | Sheehe | Towson | 2007 |
| D | Tim | Shaeffer | UMBC | 2007 |
| A | Ben | Schatz | Penn State | 2007 |
| A | Dom | Scalzo | Rutgers | 2007 |
| M | Ryan | Sankey | Cabrini | 2007 |
| M | Michael | Roe | Drexel | 2007 |
| G | Steve | Rastivo | North Carolina | 2007 |
| M | Chris | Powers | Ursinus | 2007 |
| M | Mike | Parker | Washington | 2007 |
| M | Adam | Paranka | Air Forice | 2007 |
| A | Tom | Palasek | Johns Hopkins | 2007 |
| D | Grant | Oliver | Maryland | 2007 |
| A | Eric | Newman | St. Lawrence | 2007 |
| D | Jonathan | Neri | Ithaca | 2007 |
| A | Matt | Mirabito | Le Moyne | 2007 |
| M | Evan | McGoogan | Navy | 2007 |
| M | Jay | Mann | Navy | 2007 |
| D | Brendan | Lee | Robert Morris | 2007 |
| A | Drew | Larson | Belarmine | 2007 |
| M | Tyler | Kimball | Navy | 2007 |
| D | Billy | Kerr | York | 2007 |
| D | John | Kenyon | Towson | 2007 |
| A | Sean | Hickey | Salisbury | 2007 |
| A | Dakota | Heath | US Army | 2007 |
| G | Dylan | Heath | Army | 2007 |
| A | Brian | Hantzis | Delaware | 2007 |
| A | Eric | Hanover | Messiah | 2007 |
| M | Tyler | Granelli | Syracuse | 2007 |
| M | Kyle | Gallahger | Salisbury | 2007 |
| G | Justin | Flynn | Butler | 2007 |
| D | Connor | Fitzgerald | Delaware | 2007 |
| G | Tyler | Fiorito | Princeton | 2007 |
| A | Sean | Finegan | Delaware | 2007 |
| M | Mike | Fandrich | SUNY Geneseo | 2007 |
| A | Connor | English | Virginia | 2007 |
| M | Alex | Del Balso | Dartmouth | 2007 |
| A | Clark | De Geer | Jacksonville | 2007 |
| M | George | David | Conneticut College | 2007 |
| A | Jeff | Cohen | Harvard | 2007 |
| M | Matt | Cannone | Salisbury | 2007 |
| D | Brett | Burnette | Clemson | 2007 |
| G | Joe | Banno | Haverford | 2007 |
| M | Patrick | Baire | RPI | 2007 |
| D | Mitch | Bailey | St. John Fisher | 2007 |
| D | Zach | Badalucco | Marist | 2007 |
| G | Frank | Auletti | Siena | 2007 |
| D | Justin | Annunziatto | NYIT | 2007 |
| A | Derek | Akner | Hobart | 2007 |
| A | Nicholas | Scalzo | Jacksonville | 2008 |
| D | Walter | Rodenhouse | Mercyhurst | 2008 |
| M | Patrick | Riffee | Ohio State | 2008 |
| M | Brian | Meenan | Denver | 2008 |
| A | Jason | McFadden | Georgetown | 2008 |
| D | Christopher | Lightner | Johns Hopkins | 2008 |
| D | William | Leighton-Armah | North Carolina | 2008 |
| M | Frankie | Kelly IV | North Carolina | 2008 |
| M | Aaron | Jones | Hofstra | 2008 |
| D | Tom | Hart | Loyola | 2008 |
| G | Austin | Geisler | Virginia | 2008 |
| M | Evan | Fatheree | Arizona State | 2008 |
| A | Patrick | Fanshaw | Loyola | 2008 |
| D | Patrick | Dougherty | Undecided | 2008 |
| G | Adam | Cohen | UMBC | 2008 |
| M | Nick | Caton | Jacksonville | 2008 |
| M | Drew | Belinsky | Penn | 2008 |
| D | Thomas | Applegate | Bellarmine | 2008 |
| M | Matt | Zacaroli | Conneticut Collge | 2009 |
| D | Giancarlo | Sangiacomo | Providence | 2009 |
| D | Bret | Newman | Ohio State | 2009 |
| A | Adam | Narwicz | Gettysburg | 2009 |
| M | Michael | Messina | Syracuse | 2009 |
| G | Nick | King | Penn State | 2009 |
| M | Frankie | Kelly IV | North Carolina | 2009 |
| M | David | Kelly | Rutgers | 2009 |
| M | Derek | Kehoe | Ohio State | 2009 |
| G | Austin | Geisler | Virginia | 2009 |
| D | Adam | Fingar | Hartford | 2009 |
| D | Ryan | Everson | Navy | 2009 |
| D | Gary | Davies | Fairfield | 2009 |
| D | Ralph | D'Agostino | Syracuse | 2009 |
| A | Jimmy | Bitter | North Carolina | 2009 |
| A | Brandon | Benn | Johns Hopkins | 2009 |
| M | Drew | Belinsky | Penn | 2009 |
| A | Deven | Alves | UMBC | 2009 |
| M | Ryan | Yunker | Bryant | 2010 |
| A | Zach | Reed | Hobart | 2010 |
| A | Adam | Narwicz | Gettysburg | 2010 |
| M | Nathan | Miller | Army | 2010 |
| D | Jordan | Latendresse | Navy | 2010 |
| G | Ryan | Laplante | Denver | 2010 |
| M | Johnny | Kelly | Ohio State | 2010 |
| M | Stephen | Kelly | North Carolina | 2010 |
| A | Patrick | Kelly | North Carolina | 2010 |
| D | Jeff | Hale | High Point | 2010 |
| D | Peter | Hagen | Undecided | 2010 |
| A | Brady | Faby | Johns Hopkins | 2010 |
| M | Mitchell | Dupere | High Point | 2010 |
| M | Brenny | Daly | Syracuse | 2010 |
| D | Ralph | D'Agostino | Syracuse | 2010 |
| A | Jimmy | Bitter | North Carolina | 2010 |
| M | Danny | Barcklow | Delaware | 2010 |
| D | Jake | Bailey | North Carolina | 2010 |
| G | Tyler | Avallone | Syracuse | 2010 |
| M | Patrick | Worstell | Syracuse | 2011 |
| A | Zach | Wood | Virginia | 2011 |
| D | Travis | Wood | Johns Hopkins | 2011 |
| D | Brian | Wegner | Denver | 2011 |
| A | Dylan | Maltz | Syracuse | 2011 |
| A | Ryan | Lukacovic | Virginia | 2011 |
| M | Johnny | Kelly | Ohio State | 2011 |
| M | Stephen | Kelly | North Carolina | 2011 |
| M | Kacy | Kapinos | Ohio State | 2011 |
| G | Alex | Joyce | Georgetown | 2011 |
| M | Bennett | Jonas | Ohio State | 2011 |
| D | Robby | Haus | Ohio State | 2011 |
| D | Stephen | Gutierrez | UMBC | 2011 |
| M | Collins | Gantz | Bryant | 2011 |
| D | Evan | Connell | North Carolina | 2011 |
| M | Anthony | Ciammaichella | Marquette | 2011 |
| M | John | Belz | Maryland | 2011 |
| G | Tyler | Avallone | Syracuse | 2011 |
| A | Bear | Altemus | Princeton | 2011 |
| D | Travis | Wood | Johns Hopkins | 2012 |
| D | Brian | Wegner | Denver | 2012 |
| D | Will | Reynolds | Princeton | 2012 |
| D | Tyler | Mayes | Towson | 2012 |
| A | Dylan | Maltz | Syracuse | 2012 |
| A | Ryan | Lukacovic | Virginia | 2012 |
| M | Trevor | Kupecky | Hofstra | 2012 |
| M | Blake | Knobloch | Bryant | 2012 |
| M | Stephen | Kelly | North Carolina | 2012 |
| M | Ryan | Harnisch | Denver | 2012 |
| A | Justin | Guterding | Duke | 2012 |
| A | Jack | Grass | Johns Hopkins | 2012 |
| M | Grant | Gould | Air Force | 2012 |
| M | Jordan | Germershausen | Loyola | 2012 |
| G | Danny | Fowler | Duke | 2012 |
| D | Charlie | Ford | Georgetown | 2012 |
| D | Brian | Dunne | Duke | 2012 |
| M | John | Belz | Maryland | 2012 |
| D | Luc | Bailey | Ohio State | 2012 |
| A | Bear | Altemus | Princeton | 2012 |
| A | Cameron | Ziegler | Bryant | 2013 |
| D | Matthew | Wysota | Villanova | 2013 |
| A | Nicklaus | Wood | Virginia | 2013 |
| D | Peter | Welch | Duke | 2013 |
| M | Joel | Tinney | Johns Hopkins | 2013 |
| D | Aran | Roberts | Princeton | 2013 |
| M | Colin | Riehl | Marquette | 2013 |
| G | William | Railey | Virginia | 2013 |
| M | Riley | Peters | Fairfield | 2013 |
| A | Sean | O'Brien | Bucknell | 2013 |
| M | Jack | Moran | Furman | 2013 |
| M | Carney | Mahon | Harvard | 2013 |
| M | Conor | Mackie | Yale | 2013 |
| D | Michael | Lanahan Jr. | High Point | 2013 |
| D | Joseph | Kenna | North Carolina | 2013 |
| G | Matt | Isnardi | Army | 2013 |
| M | Ryan | Harnisch | Denver | 2013 |
| M | Hunter | Edington | Manhattan | 2013 |
| M | Sean | Cerrone | Villanova | 2013 |
| A | Townsend | Brown | Virginia | 2013 |
| D | Benny | Borgognone | Fairfield | 2013 |
| M | Sam | Bonafede | Princeton | 2013 |
| M | Curtis | Zappala | Maryland | 2014 |
| D | Mike | Wegner | Loyola | 2014 |
| D | Cade | Van Raaphorst | Duke | 2014 |
| M | Drew | Supinski | Johns Hopkins | 2014 |
| G | Hunter | Sells | Johns Hopkins | 2014 |
| A | Colton | Rupp | Johns Hopkins | 2014 |
| D | Jack | Rowlett | North Carolina | 2014 |
| M | Alex | Roesner | Penn | 2014 |
| D | Jake | Peden | North Carolina | 2014 |
| M | Jack | Olson | Johns Hopkins | 2014 |
| M | Thomas | O'Connell | Maryland | 2014 |
| M | Alex | McGovern | North Carolina | 2014 |
| A | Andy | Matthews | North Carolina | 2014 |
| M | Charles | Kelly III | North Carolina | 2014 |
| A | Timmy | Kelly | North Carolina | 2014 |
| D | Jack | Halpert | North Carolina | 2014 |
| A | Henry | Grass | Johns Hopkins | 2014 |
| M | Ryan | Conrad | Virginia | 2014 |
| G | AJ | Barretto | Army | 2014 |
| A | Grant | Ament | Penn State | 2014 |
| M | Jack | Wilson | Maryland | 2015 |
| D | Jack | Welding | Maryland | 2015 |
| F/O | Danny | Varello | Syracuse | 2015 |
| A | Forry | Smith | Johns Hopkins | 2015 |
| D | John | Railey | Loyola | 2015 |
| M | Kevin | Quigley | Duke | 2015 |
| G | Jack | Pezzulla | North Carolina | 2015 |
| M | Avery | Myers | Michigan | 2015 |
| D | Ryan | McNulty | Loyola | 2015 |
| D | Matthew | McIlroy | Denver | 2015 |
| M | Nick | McEvoy | Penn State | 2015 |
| D | Patrick | Lyons | North Carolina | 2015 |
| M | Terry | Lindsay | Duke | 2015 |
| D | Colin | Hayek | Maryland | 2015 |
| A | Samuel | Harnisch | Denver | 2015 |
| M | Christain | Ford | Michigan | 2015 |
| M | Luke | Desperito | Virginia | 2015 |
| G | Alex | DeMarco | Penn | 2015 |
| A | Cal | Costa | Ohio State | 2015 |
| LSM | Christopher | Walker | Georgetown | 2016 |
| A | Thomas | Tenney | Denver | 2016 |
| G | Jake | Stout | Towson | 2016 |
| M | Colby | Smith | Ohio State | 2016 |
| D | Koby | Smith | Towson | 2016 |
| F/O | Justin | Shockey | Maryland | 2016 |
| D | Raines | Shamburger | Duke | 2016 |
| M | Steven | Schneider | North Carolina | 2016 |
| M | Nakeie | Montgomery | Duke | 2016 |
| M | Matthew | Licciardi | Cornel | 2016 |
| A | Jack | Keogh | Johns Hopkins | 2016 |
| G | Preston | Heard | Duke | 2016 |
| M | Wilson | Hand | Maryland | 2016 |
| A | Christopher | Gray | North Carolina | 2016 |
| M | Connor | DeSimone | Johns Hopkins | 2016 |
| A | Brendan | Curry | Syracuse | 2016 |
| LSM | Ben | Cirella | Michigan | 2016 |
| D | Joey | Carrington | North Carolina | 2016 |
| D | Hank | Bass | Undecided | 2016 |
| A | JP | Basile | Duke | 2016 |
| M | James | Avanzato | Maryland | 2016 |
| M | Tate | Young | Penn | 2017 |
| A | Skyler | Wilson | Denver | 2017 |
| M | Griffin | Wilson | Denver | 2017 |
| M | Griffin | Westlin | Johns Hopkins | 2017 |
| D | George | Walsh | Ohio State | 2017 |
| M | Zachary | Tucci | Harvard | 2017 |
| D | Wilson | Stephenson | Duke | 2017 |
| A | Nicky | Solomon | North Carolina | 2017 |
| M | Harrison | Schertzinger | North Carolina | 2017 |
| M | Henry | Schertzinger | North Carolina | 2017 |
| M | Garrett | Ruff | Cornell | 2017 |
| D | Patrick | Mcilroy | Lehigh | 2017 |
| D | Frank | Marinello | Duke | 2017 |
| M | Sean | Kuttin | Yale | 2017 |
| A | Jacob | Kelly | North Carolina | 2017 |
| A | Zachary | Green | Maryland | 2017 |
| M | Jordan | Ginder | Duke | 2017 |
| A | Griffin | Gelinas | Michigan | 2017 |
| G | Teddy | Dolan | Bingham | 2017 |
| D | Jack | DeSantis | Maryland | 2017 |
| M | Isaiah | Dawson | Harvard | 2017 |
| D | RJ | Corba | Hamliton | 2017 |
| D | Will | Bowen | North Carolina | 2017 |
| M | Nicky | Bond | Princeton | 2017 |
| G | Andrew | Bonafede | Duke | 2017 |
| G | Christian | Tomei | Ohio State | 2018 |
| A | Jake | Taylor | Notre Dame | 2018 |
| D | Jacob | Snyder | Ohio State | 2018 |
| A | Alex | Slusher | Princeton | 2018 |
| M | Jack | Sawyer | Maryland | 2018 |
| F/O | Tyler | Sandoval | Princeton | 2018 |
| M | Henry | Rentz | Navy | 2018 |
| D | Jack | Peterson | Albany | 2018 |
| M | Grant | Mitchell | Ohio State | 2018 |
| A | Connor | Mitchell | Ohio State | 2018 |
| M | Carter | Hilleary | Ohio State | 2018 |
| D | Cameron | Henry | Duke | 2018 |
| F/O | Matthew | Gunty | Brown | 2018 |
| M | Kevin | Groeninger | Bryant | 2018 |
| M | Jake | Giulieri | Virginia | 2018 |
| D | Ben | Finlay | Princeton | 2018 |
| M | Elijah | Ensor | Ohio State | 2018 |
| A | Connor | Davies | Undecided | 2018 |
| D | Parker | Byrd | North Carolina | 2018 |
| M | Elijah | Black | Ohio State | 2018 |
| D | Jack | Witherspoon | Syracuse | 2019 |
| M | Michael Paul | Thomas | Navy | 2019 |
| D | Jack | Stuzin | Yale | 2019 |
| M | Mason | Rickens | Rutgers | 2019 |
| D | Nicholas | Redd | Maryland | 2019 |
| M | Andrew | O'Berry | Harvard | 2019 |
| G | Jackson | Marshall | Maryland | 2019 |
| M | Connell | Kumar | Virginia | 2019 |
| D | Cole | Krauss | Duke | 2019 |
| A | Christopher | Kirst | Cornell | 2019 |
| M | Seth | Higgins | Loyola | 2019 |
| M | Cole | Herbert | North Carolina | 2019 |
| M | Carter | Henry | Yale | 2019 |
| A | Mikie | Harmeyer | UVA | 2019 |
| D | Wallace | Halpert | Georgetown | 2019 |
| A | TJ | Haley | Maryland | 2019 |
| A | Joey | Graham | Harvard | 2019 |
| D | Blake | Gable | North Carolina | 2019 |
| D | Dante | Fuller | Rutgers | 2019 |
| G | Gabriel | Craven | Navy | 2019 |
| M | William | Coletti | Army | 2019 |
| M | Seth | Benedict | Undecided | 2019 |
| D | Bobby | Van Buren | Ohio State | 2020 |
| M | Kevin | Tucker | Maryland | 2020 |
| M | Dante | Trader | Maryland | 2020 |
| A | Jeffery | Ricciardelli | Penn | 2020 |
| G | Matthew | Nunes | UVA | 2020 |
| M | Chase | Mullins | UNC | 2020 |
| A | Finnian | Kelly | Syracuse | 2020 |
| A | Leo | Johnson | Yale | 2020 |
| M | William | Inderlied | UVA | 2020 |
| M | Cody | Hart | UVA | 2020 |
| G | Jack | Fracyon | Penn State | 2020 |
| A | Braden | Erksa | Maryland | 2020 |
| M | Ben | Bonafede | Bucknell | 2020 |
